Monday, February 21, 2011

Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother

This was, again, one of those books that is hard to put down. Having raised children, I was curious about what this mother could possibly have to say about child rearing that I didn't already know. However, I was in for a surprise! Amy Chua was much tougher and much more disciplined than I was in my mothering. I sometimes kept my kids home from school, hated school projects because I knew that most of the parents did them, and hated the competition of all the other parents who pressured their kids to come in first in everything and anything. My kids and I did things together, napped together, and just enjoyed simple things and being together. If this sounds like pampering, it wasn't. They were told to do things on their own, deal with adversity because it "builds "character," and take the good with the bad. While Amy Chua represents the extreme of parenting,most parents could take lessons from her. I have watched most parents protecting their children's self-esteem, but not giving them the backbone they'll need to get through life. Amy Chua worked at building her children's talents so that they would be successful in life, which is different from what many parents do. Most parents push their children to succeed because their children's successes are validation to the parents--when their kids do well the parents feel they are also successful people. While I won't go so far as to say that how Amy Chua parented is the best way to parent, her approach did have some merit, as the discipline she instilled in her children would benefit everyone. Read this book- the Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother is worthwhile and thought-provoking.

1 comment:

  1. I have to say that I will always remember the days that you let me stay home from school because I had a big project due that was stressing me out because I hadn't finished it yet. As I nanny for my child, I often feel bad about how stressed she gets over simple homework assignments and how her parents make her finish them right away. No child should be "stressed" ever and especially not over a 3rd grade project. Those are years that they'll never get back and plenty of real things to stress over are to come down the line. I loved my naps after school, doing vocab homework in front of the tv, and the fact that I actually had to do my own projects (even if it wasn't as dazzling perfect as other kids). We did build character along the way (and still are) and, although I sometimes wonder where I'd be if I had stuck to one extracurricular activity, I know that you let us explore and enjoy all of the things childhood has to offer. However, now you are stuck with two adult children living in your house (did you ever guess you wouldn't be an empty nester yet?) Love you <3

    ReplyDelete